• B. Draft Chapters of Philosophy and Revolution

    The first chapter of Philosophy and Revolution (P&R) drafted in outline form by Dunayevskaya was written in the Spring of 1961 (#4316), and was entitled “Subjectivity of Self-Liberation.” By 1963, she drafted what was to became Chapter 6, then entitled “Sartre’s Search for a Method to Undermine Marxism.” Beginning in 1967, Dunayevskaya launched a sustained effort to draft the whole of P&R, writing nearly all the eventual nine chapters twice, and writing some chapters three times before they reached their final published form. A number of these drafts — as well as a brief selection of crucial correspondence about the draft chapters — has already been included in the Dunayevskaya Collection (#4144-4337). In recent years other draft chapters written between 1968 and 1972 have been located. They are added here.

  • 1. Part I? Economic Reality and the Dialectics of Liberation.

    A draft chapter completed on March 20, 1968. In a cover letter which Dunayevskaya sent out to “Dear Friends” with this draft chapter (#4295), she suggested that it was likely that this chapter would be located much later in the sequence of the book, and that a new Part I would be created, entitled “Why Hegel? Why Now?” The draft chapter included here contains material which appears in Chapter 7 of the book as published — on the “African Revolutions and the World Economy” — and Chapter 2, Section 2 — on “The 1850s: The Grundrisse, Then and Now.” For other drafts of these sections of the book, see #4176 (completed March, 1969), and #4227 (completed October, 1968).

  • 2. Hegel’s Absolutes as New Beginnings.

    A draft chapter completed Feb. 2, 1970. This is the third draft of what became chapter 1 of P&R, entitled “Absolute Negativity as New Beginning.” The first draft, completed in Jan., 1967, remains missing. The second draft, completed Oct. 13, 1968, is already included in the Collection (#4190). This third draft greatly expands the length of the chapter and Dunayevskaya’s discussion of Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind.

  • 3. Marx’s Transcendence of, and Return to. the Hegelian Dialectic.

    A draft chapter completed Nov. 11, 1970. This is the third draft of what became Chapter 2 of P&R, entitled “A New Continent of Thought.” The first draft, completed in February, 1967, is still missing. The second draft, completed in Oct., 1968, can be found in Volume VII of the Collection (#4227). Pages 26-28 of the mss. included here are missing.

  • 4. The Shock of Recognition and the Philosophic Ambivalence of Lenin.

    A draft chapter completed Feb. 28, 1970. This is the third draft of what became Chapter 3 of P&R, entitled “The Shock of Recognition and the Philosophic Ambivalence of Lenin. The first draft, completed in February, 1967, is missing. The second draft, completed in November, 1968, is already included in the Collection (#4261). Much of the material included here appears in Dunayevskaya’s article, “Lenin’s Philosophic Ambivalence,” Telos, Spring 1970.

  • 5. Leon Trotsky as Theoretician.

    A draft chapter completed Dec. 14, 1970. This is the second draft of what became Chapter 4 of P&R, entitled “Leon Trotsky as Theoretician.” The first draft is already included in the Collection (#4160). Also included here is Dunayevskaya’s draft of her Introductory comments to “Part II -Alternatives,” completed Dec. 14, 1970. This is the section of the book as published which is entitled “On the Eve of World War II: Depression in the Economy and in Thought.” An earlier draft of these introductory pages is already included in the Collection (#4269).

  • 6. Jean-Paul Sartre.

    A draft chapter probably completed in April, 1971. This is the second draft of what became Chapter 6 of P&R, entitled “Jean-Paul Sartre: Outsider Looking In.” The first draft of this chapter was written as a “Weekly Political Letter” in September, 1963, and is already included in this Collection (#4144).

  • 7. New Passions and New Forces.

    A draft chapter completed about May 25, 1971. This chapter was originally drafted in “outline” form in April, 1969, after Dunayevskaya’s participation in the “Black/Red Conference,” a meeting of Black workers, civil rights activists and Marxist-Humanists. For the original outline, see #4283.

  • 8. Introduction to Philosophy and Revolution.

    Draft completed Nov. 7, 1971. No previous draft of the Introduction is known. This draft, however, differs from the Introduction as published. Handnotes on the mss. are by Dunayevskaya.

  • 9. Final manuscript of Philosophy and Revolution.

    Submitted to publishers Jan. 31, 1972. This is the final typed mss. of P&R. It is included here so that comparisons can be made with the book as published. Dunayevskaya introduced many changes in the book between Jan. 1972 and her release of the page proofs in April, 1973. By comparing this final typed mss. with the book as published, Dunayevskaya’s last additions and corrections to the book can be discerned.

  • C. Correspondence, Presentations and Notes on the Writing of Philosophy and Revolution, January, 1958 – September, 1960

  • 1. Dunayevskaya letter to Herbert Marcuse, written Jan. 28, 1958.

    One month after the publication of Marxism and Freedom (M&F), Dunayevskaya is “already thinking of a ‘supplement’” on “Hegel’s Absolute Idea.” (This letter and most of the other correspondence between Dunayevskaya and Marcuse are also included in Vol. XII of the Dunayevskaya Collection. They appear again here because of their importance in the development of Philosophy and Revolution (P&R).)

  • 3. Dunayevskaya letter to Marcuse, written July 15, 1958

    . On Absolute Method within the Hegelian Absolutes, in Marx’s day and in our day. Asks for Marcuse’s help in “further development” of these ideas.

  • 5. Final lecture on Marxism and Freedom, given by Dunayevskaya Jan. 18, 1959,

    in Detroit. Included here are Dunayevskaya’s notes for the talk. A discussion of Hegel’s Absolutes, Marx’s Absolutes and our age of absolutes; emphasis not on the “unity of Theory and Practice,” but “the incompletion of each by itself.” Includes reexamination of Dunayevskaya’s 1953 Letters on Hegel’s Absolutes.

  • 7. Dunayevskaya letter to Buttinger, written Dec. 15, 1959.

    Written after Dunayevskaya’s return from a trip to Europe which included a conference of state-capitalist tendencies. (Documents from this trip are included in Vol. XII of the Dunayevskaya Collection; see #9364-9572.) Dunayevskaya reports on discussions with Martin Milligan and possible collaboration with him “on any work on Hegel.”

  • 8. Dunayevskaya letter to “Si” (Charles Denby), written March 10, 1960.

    On Maurice Merleau-Ponty’s “Marxism and Philosophy,” as Dunayevskaya “re-read it with Automation in mind.” Denby was at that time working on a News & Letters pamphlet entitled Workers Battle Automation (1960, #2843).

  • 9. “World View of the Negro Question.” Transcript of a lecture by Dunayevskaya given May 14, 1960, as part of a series of classes based on M&F.

    On the Black Dimension in Africa and America; develops ideas discussed in Dunayevskaya’s 1959 work, Nationalism, Communism, Marxist-Humanism and the Afro-Asian Revolutions (#2688). Transcript not corrected by Dunayevskaya; tape ran out before conclusion of lecture.

  • 10. Excerpts from “From Organizational-Consciousness to Organization Building.” Report to the Convention of News and Letters Committees, given by Dunayevskaya in Sept. 1960.

    The section entitled “The Average Man as Philosopher and the New Book” contains the first public projection by Dunayevskaya, of the work that was to become P&R.

  • D. Correspondence and Notes on the Writing of Philosophy and Revolution, October, 1960 – June, 1961.

  • 1. Letters and Summations of Hegelian Philosophy relative to new book, begun 10/12/60, ended 1/26/61.

    Two listings by Dunayevskaya of her notes and correspondence which she considered work on what became P&R. Written January, 1961. Included in her list are several works which have appeared elsewhere in the Dunayevskaya Collection, and are not reproduced in this section. These are: Letters on the Absolute Idea, 1953 (#1797); Lecture at Leeds University on “Marx’s Debt to Hegel,” 1959 (#9478); “Summaries of Hegel’s Major Writings,” 1960-61, (#2806).

  • 4. Dunayevskaya letter to Saul Blackman, written Oct. 17, 1960.

    A “rough outline” of the “points of the new book.” To be read along with Dunayevskaya’s letter to Marcuse written one day earlier. Gives the new book the title: “Philosophic Foundations of Man’s Struggles for Freedom in Colonial Countries,” though “no such title would actually be used.”

  • 6. Dunayevskaya letter to Joseph Buttinger, written Oct. 20, 1960.

    On Hegel’s Phenomenology of Mind, Science of Logic, Encyclopedia of Philosophical Sciences as part of Dunayevskaya’s work on “philosophic foundations of the struggles for freedom.”

  • 8. Olga Domanski letter to “Walt and Betty,” written Nov. 12, 1960.

    A discussion (at Dunayevskaya’s request) of questions on science and Marxism raised in Dunayevskaya’s Oct. 12, 1960 letter to Louis Gogol; on Einstein and “unified field theory.”

  • 9. The Philosophic Foundations for the Struggles for Freedom in the Latin American and Afro-Asian Countries.

    Transcript of a lecture by Raya Dunayevskaya given in Detroit, Nov. 13, 1960. This is the first presentation on Dunayevskaya’s work on the new book. Transcript not corrected by Dunayevskaya.

  • 10. Dunayevskaya letter to Marcuse, written Nov. 22, 1960.

    On Bukharin’s Historical Materialism and Hegel’s Absolute Idea; discusses Dunayevskaya’s 1953 letters on Hegel’s Absolutes and their expression in M&F.

  • 12. Dunayevskaya letter to A.N.L. Wina, written Dec. 16, 1960.

    On Daniel Bell’s book, The End of Ideology; on Wina’s questions on ideas and freedom struggles in Africa. Wina was active in liberation movements in Northern Rhodesia.

  • 13. Marcuse letter to Dunayevskaya, written Dec. 22, 1960.

    A response to Dunayevskaya’s letters of Oct. 16 and Nov. 22, 1960. Asks “why you need the Absolute Idea to say what you want to say.” In this period, Dunayevskaya had just completed her summary of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Mind and was beginning work on a summary of the Science of Logic. For the texts of these summaries, see #2806.

  • 15. Dunayevskaya letter to Marcuse, written Jan. 12, 1961.

    A response to Marcuse’s letter of Dec. 22, 1960. On the Absolute Idea in Hegel and its ramifications in Marx, in Lenin, and in Dunayevskaya’s own work.

  • 17. Dunayevskaya letter to “Dear Friends,” written Jan. 25, 1961.

    On her summation of Hegel’s Science of Logic, just completed. For Dunayevskaya’s letter on her summary of Hegel’s Phenomenology, see #12333.

  • 18. Olga Domanski letter to Dunayevskaya, written Feb. 2, 1961.

    On Domanski’s study of Dunayevskaya’s letters to Marcuse and summaries of Hegel’s works. This is the only substantive response to the “philosophical letters” of Oct. 1960 – Jan. 1961 that Dunayevskaya received.

  • 19. Some Notes for Saturday’s Presentation to the REB.

    Notes by Dunayevskaya for a talk to the Resident Editorial Board of News and Letters Committees, given Feb. 4, 1961 in Detroit. On her 1953 Letters on Hegel’s Absolutes and the 1960-61 new “philosophical letters.” Also included here are Resident Editorial Board minutes on Dunayevskaya’s presentation, given Feb. 4, 1961.

  • 21. Dunayevskaya letter to “Com. Spence” (Jonathan Spence), written Feb. 27, 1961.

    Opens discussion on Spence’s area of specialization — China — with concepts from the Phenomenology of Mind which relate to Mao Tse-tung. In this period Dunayevskaya had just completed the third in her series of Hegel summaries, her notes on Hegel’s Smaller Logic from the Encyclopedia of Philosophical Sciences.

  • 22. Dunayevskaya letter to Jonathan Spence, written June 1, 1961.

    On the “context” of Dunayevskaya’s discussions with Spence on China, the Absolute Idea. A discussion of Absolute Idea in Hegel’s Science of Logic; Dunayevskaya traces Hegel’s text, relates it to Marx, to Lenin, and to post-World War II freedom struggles. This letter was intended “as basis for my actual writing of that chapter on the Absolute Idea in my book.” For other 1961 letters exchanged by Spence and Dunayevskaya, see #12791ff.

  • 23. A Brief Outline of the New Book.

    A “Weekly Political Letter” written June 3, 1961 by Dunayevskaya. Accompanies copies of Dunayevskaya’s letter to Jonathan Spence; gives proposed frontispiece quotes by Hegel and Marx for the book; outlines five parts. The “Weekly Political Letters” series was begun by Dunayevskaya April 22, 1961, in response to the U.S.-sponsored “Bay of Pigs” invasion of Cuba. After this letter was written, Dunayevskaya drafted a first chapter of the new book in outline form, entitled “Subjectivity of Self-liberation.” (#4317)

  • E. Correspondence, Presentations and Notes on the Writing of Philosophy and Revolution, September 1961 – December 1966.

  • 1. Dunayevskaya letter to Olga Domanski, written Sept. 21, 1961 (excerpts).

    Suggestions for Domanski’s summation of the “Executive session” of the Sept. 1961 News and Letters Committees Plenum. On the relationship of the work on the new book to organization and to responses to current world events.

  • 2. Dunayevskaya letter to Joseph Buttinger, written Oct. 1, 1961.

    On Dunayevskaya’s plans for her 1962 trip to Africa and the way the African trip relates to the new book. Included also is Dunayevskaya’s draft of the letter.

  • 3. Dunayevskaya letter to “Dear Friends,” written Nov. 29, 1961.

    On plans for the Africa trip and organizational responsibilities. Dunayevskaya asks that her June 3, 1961 Outline of the new book be re-studied. In this period News and Letters Committees had just published a new pamphlet, Freedom Riders Speak for Themselves.

  • 6. Dunayevskaya letter to Olga Domanski, written April 23, 1962.

    Written during Dunayevskaya’s April-May 1962 trip to West Africa. (For letters written during this trip, see Vol. XII, #9573-9677.) Discusses the relationship between perspectives for the new book and the experience of the African trip.

  • 7. Report to the Resident Editorial Board (REB) of News and Letters Committees on “Some Ramifications of the African and British trips.”

    Dunayevskaya’s report was given July 10, 1962. Included here are excerpts from the REB minutes of that report.

  • 8. Dunayevskaya letter to Joseph Buttinger, written Jan. 1, 1963.

    On “the internalization of the African experience” for the work on the book. In this period Dunayevskaya was at work on American Civilization on Trial.

  • 9. A. James Gregor letter to Dunayevskaya, written June 7, 1963

    . A continuation of correspondence between Dunayevskaya and Gregor, an author of articles on Marx’s 1844 manuscripts. Gregor comments on the Hegel-Marx relationship.

  • 11. Dunayevskaya letters to Julius Jacobson, (New Politics, New York), written Oct. 3, 1963, and to George Heltai (The Review, Belgium), written Oct. 8, 1963.

    Dunayevskaya submits her review of Jean-Paul Sartre’s Search for a Method for publication. This review served as the first draft of what became Chapter 6 of P&R, “Jean-Paul Sartre: Outsider Looking In.”

  • 12. Dunayevskaya letter to Bess Gogol, written Oct. 19, 1963.

    On the relationship of the supplement to Marxism and Freedom (second edition, 1964) on “The Challenge of Mao Tse-tung,” to the work on the new book.

  • 13. Dunayevskaya letter to Erich Fromm, written Nov. 21, 1963.

    An appeal by Dunayevskaya “for a dialogue on Hegel between us”; includes a discussion of Sartre and the section on “Spirit in Self-Estrangement” from Hegel’s Phenomenology of Mind.

  • 16. Dunayevskaya letter to Eugene Walker, written June 9, 1964.

    Walker was then in Mississippi during Mississippi Freedom Summer. On Marcuse’s 1960 preface to Reason and Revolution, especially on Marcuse’s view of science and Dunayevskaya’s.

  • 17. Dunayevskaya presentation on “Stewardship of Leadership” to Resident Editorial Board of News and Letters Committees given July 8, 1964 (excerpts)

    . On “where we must begin on uncharted roads — in the 1953 Letters on the Absolute Idea.”

  • 18. Dunayevskaya letter to Bess Gogol and Eugene Walker, written Sept. 27, 1964.

    On Dunayevskaya’s re-reading of Marcuse’s 1960 preface to Reason and Revolution, “pin-pointing the philosophic point that separates us.”

  • 19. Dunayevskaya letter to Bess Gogol and Eugene Walker, written Oct. 1, 1964.

    On “the philosophic problems of the new book.” Dunayevskaya offers “an outline of one of the parts,” tentatively titled “Why Hegel? Why Now?” Suggests that the title of the new book might be Philosophy and Human Liberation.

  • 23. Dunayevskaya letter to Marcuse, written Oct. 27, 1964.

    An “informal” outline of a chapter of “my new work (which I lean to calling Philosophy and Revolution) that deals with ‘Why Hegel? Why Now?.’”

  • 24. Report on “Philosophical Letters and Trip to New York,” given by Dunayevskaya to REB, meeting of News and Letters Committees, Nov. 4, 1964 (excerpts).

    Discussion of philosophical letters written by Dunayevskaya in Sept.-Oct., 1964.

  • 25. Dunayevskaya letter to Peter Bergmann, written Nov. 8, 1964.

    Asks for assistance with translation of a passage from Marx’s Grundrisse. Dunayevskaya wished to check Marcuse’s translation of this passage. (Bergmann’s reply, including his translation, is included in the Chapter files for P&R. — Marx, Section 2.)

  • 26. Dunayevskaya letter to “Dear Colleagues,” written Nov. 14, 1964

    . Accompanies Dunayevskaya’s review of Marcuse’s One-Dimensional Man. (The review was published in The Activist, 1964, and is included in Vol. XII of the Dunayevskaya Collection, #10069.)

  • 28. Special Meeting on the Philosophic Problems of the New Book.

    Report to the Resident Editorial Board of News and Letters Committees given by Dunayevskaya, Nov. 29, 1964. Included here are the REB minutes.

  • 31. Dunayevskaya letter to Charles A. Moore, editor, Philosophy East and West, written Jan. 26, 1965.

    Submits her article, “Sartre’s Search for a Method to Undermine Marxism,” for publication. Calls it “chapter in my projected work, tentatively entitled Philosophy and Revolution.” In March, 1965, Dunayevskaya wrote a review of Sartre’s The Words for the Oberlin student journal, The Activist. (This review is included in the Collection, #3363.)

  • 32. Dunayevskaya letter to “Dear Colleagues,” written July 22, 1965.

    On her forthcoming trip to Japan and the need to focus on the writing of the new book. In the preceding months, Dunayevskaya had been at work on a new pamphlet published by News and Letters Committees, The Free Speech Movement and the Negro Revolution.

  • 35. Dunayevskaya letter to “Com. Yukiyama” (Yoshimasa Yukiyama), written Sept. 14, 1965.

    On the post-World War II world and the problems of revolutionary thought today; asks for a dialogue in advance of Dunayevskaya’s trip.

  • 36. Erich Fromm letter to Dunayevskaya, written Dec. 13, 1965.

    Sends his report to the Guggenheim Foundation on Dunayevskaya. From November, 1965 through January, 1966, Dunayevskaya was on a trip to Hong Kong and Japan. For letters written during this trip, see #9678-9888.

  • 41. Dunayevskaya letter to Nat Simon, written May 26, 1966.

    Seeks copies of Georg Lukacs’ “What is Orthodox Marxism?”; German edition of Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind; Russian edition of Marx’s doctoral thesis.

  • 43. Stewardship of Leadership.

    Notes by Dunayevskaya for report to the Executive session of Convention of News and Letters committees (excerpts), given Sept. 3, 1966. On the development of Philosophy and Revolution and its ramifications for organization.

  • 48. Dunayevskaya letter to “S” (East Europe), written Nov. 25, 1966.

    Asks him to attempt a draft chapter of Philosophy and Revolution on “the relationship of the advanced to the technologically backward countries.” Also included here are excerpts from Dunayevskaya’s follow-up letter, written Dec. 17, 1966, on the proposed chapter.